Imagine Stephen King’s Misery colliding with Stranger Things and Spider-Man, and you’ll have a sense of the unique theatrical experience offered by I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire at Southwark Playhouse Borough. This venue has become my go-to spot for exceptional theatre, and this production only solidifies its standing.
Following a successful off-Broadway run in 2023, I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire has made its off-West End debut, transforming Southwark Playhouse into a shrine dedicated to Tobey Maguire. From the moment you step inside, Maguire’s image is everywhere – even in the toilets. The set, designed by Rodrigo Hernandez Martinez, perfectly captures a 90s teenage bedroom, evoking nostalgia and setting the stage for the performance.
A Sinister Take on Teen Obsession
The play, set in 2004, centres on Shelby Hinkley, the president of the North American/Antarctic branch of the Tobey Maguire fan club. Shelby’s obsession leads her to kidnap Tobey Maguire (Anders Hayward) and chain him in her basement, hoping he will develop Stockholm Syndrome. This bizarre premise sets the tone for a darkly comedic and thrilling narrative.
Shelby’s difficult home life, with a neglectful mother (voiced by Kyle Birch) and a father in prison, paints her as a sympathetic yet sinister character. Tessa Albertson’s portrayal of Shelby is exceptional, balancing her childish excitement with a chilling detachment, creating an atmosphere of unease.
Unravelling Tobey Maguire
As Shelby and Tobey interact, the facade of Maguire’s public persona begins to crumble. Shelby discovers the man she idolised is flawed, leading her to reconsider her feelings. Tobey, realising his only chance of escape is to feign Stockholm Syndrome, plays along until an unexpected visit from a real estate agent (Kyle Birch) threatens Shelby’s plans.
Balancing Dark Themes with Humour
I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire skilfully balances dark themes of obsession, mental health, and abuse with humour. The set and costumes, designed by Reuben Speed, evoke early 2000s nostalgia, enhancing the comedic undertone. The script by Samantha Hurley is sharp and filled with pop culture references, making the audience laugh even as the tension builds.
Kyle Birch’s multiple roles, especially as a sassy poster of Tobey Maguire, add to the humour. However, the show does have its weaker moments, such as a scene where Tobey laments his fame, which felt out of place and disrupted the story’s intensity.
Despite these minor flaws, the show is a compelling blend of absurd comedy and dark thriller, offering moments of genuine emotion. Tessa Albertson’s performance as Shelby and Anders Hayward’s portrayal of Tobey are standout elements, making the show a memorable experience.
A Unique Theatrical Experience
Rodrigo Hernandez Martinez’s set design extends beyond the stage, immersing the audience in Shelby’s obsessive world. The show’s exploration of obsession and parasocial relationships feels timeless, resonating with audiences of all ages.
I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire is a brazen and absurdly funny production, earning both shock and laughter from the audience. It’s a standout in this summer’s theatrical offerings.
I’m Gonna Marry You Tobey Maguire is playing at Southwark Playhouse Borough until 10 August 2024. For tickets and information, visit Southwark Playhouse.